Self-defence workshop for women, 21 or 28 November: three hours of practical skills. Sign-ups are open.

Koans: questions without an answer in Chan meditation

Koans: questions without an answer in Chan meditation

“What is the sound of one hand clapping?” Many people know this line, even those who have never meditated. It is a koan - a short question or story from the Chan (in Japan, Zen) tradition that cannot be solved with logic. That is exactly its purpose.

Where koans come from

The word koan comes from the Chinese gong’an (公案), meaning “public case”, like a court case. They are recorded conversations and encounters between teachers and students of Chan Buddhism, mostly from the Tang and Song dynasties. Later they were gathered into collections that are still used today.

A few well-known examples

  • The sound of one hand. Two hands make a sound. What is the sound of one?
  • Mu. A monk asks master Zhaozhou: “Does a dog have Buddha nature?” The master answers: “Wu” (in Japanese “mu”) - “no”.
  • Your face before birth. What was your original face before your parents were born?

Why they have no answer

A koan is not a riddle waiting for the right solution. The mind tries to explain, compare and untangle it - and tires itself out. At the moment it stops searching, something else can open: direct experience not mediated by explanation. The tradition calls this insight.

How koans are used

In some schools a student carries one koan in meditation for a long time and discusses it with the teacher. In others koans are used less or not at all, and the emphasis is on silent sitting and observation. In our practice a koan can be a prompt for reflection, but the basis remains sitting and attention on the breath.

What koans tell us today

Perhaps above all that not everything can be understood by thinking. That it is sometimes worth carrying a question with you without looking for an answer at once. And that humour, of which there is plenty in koans, has its place in serious practice too.

More on meditation on the Chan meditation in Ljubljana page.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to use koans in meditation? No. Our basis is silent sitting and attention on the breath.

Does a koan have a correct answer? Not in a logical sense. The purpose is experience, not a solution.

Are koans religious? They come from the Buddhist tradition, but you can use them as a prompt for reflection without belief.

← Back to the blog

The first step is the hardest.
Take it with us.

or write to us at andrej@bodymindljubljana.si